Looking for Local or Real Estate Information? Call Or Text Us Anytime 352-223-9238

Mount Dora Pizza

Best Pizza in Mount Dora & Beyond

Best Pizza in Mount Dora & Beyond

Mount Dora’s Pizza Paradiso: A Slice of Heaven in Every Bite!

Welcome to Mount Dora, where the pizzas are as full of character as the town itself! Nestled among the rolling hills and serene lakes of Lake County, Mount Dora is not just a haven for artists and boaters but also a paradise for pizza enthusiasts. Let’s embark on a gastronomic journey through the town’s most talked-about pizzerias – no passport required, just bring your appetite!

PizzAmoré: Love at First Slice!

If you haven’t been serenaded by the sizzle of a PizzAmoré pie fresh out of the oven, are you even living? This gem is where the dough meets delight, and every slice is a testament to the town’s love affair with Italian cuisine. From the classic Margherita to the daringly delicious gluten-free options, PizzAmoré is the kind of place where “more” is not just a suggestion, it’s a promise.

Shadrach’s Fiery Furnace: Where the Heat Is Sweet!

The new kid on the block, Shadrach’s Fiery Furnace Pizza Co., has already turned up the heat on the Mount Dora pizza scene. With a wood-fired oven that could tell tales of Neapolitan mastery, this spot is a slice of rustic charm right on Donnelly Street. It’s where you go when you want your pizza served with a side of “cozy community vibes” and a sprinkle of “family-owned magic.”

El Marie Pizzeria: The Sublime Sub Stop!

A hop, skip, and a jump away in Eustis, El Marie Pizzeria and Sub Shoppe is shaking things up with a combo that has locals and visitors hooked – pizza and subs! This isn’t your average pizzeria; it’s a culinary crossroad where Italian tradition meets American gusto. Whether it’s a meat-packed sub or a classic pepperoni pizza, El Marie is the place to quell your cravings.


There you have it, folks – a trifecta of pizza perfection. In Mount Dora, every pizzeria has its own story, baked into every crust and simmering in every sauce. So whether you’re a local or just cruising through, make sure to stop by these havens of hand-tossed happiness. Who knows, you might just find your “pizza the heart” in this quaint Florida town!  Check below for some other great pizza options around town!

Join Us!

Join our VIP list and get a week’s worth of fun, local events delivered to your inbox weekly.

* indicates required

Search for homes

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Get a list of the newest Lake County listings delivered to your inbox.
NEW LISTINGS